Responses to my essay
I've been getting very positive feedback in response to my essay. I've also been interested in criticism (which I always value highly), and Joe Perez has written a passionate rebuttal, to which I wrote a counter-reply. It's all on Frank Visser's Integral World site now for anyone who wants to follow the whole thing
Although Joe and I may differ intellectually (I mean it is really only on the matter of KW, he likes Wilber and AQAL while I take a contrary position) I think highly of him, and feel that at bottom Integralism is still about a common goal (more on this in a follow up post). He sent me a short friendly email concerning my reply to his critique. But not suire if the debate is going any further for now. So if anyone else wants to jump in on either side of the debate, or alternatively propose their own pov, that would help carry things along
- "Redefining Integral" - my original essay
- "Questioning Kazlev's Redefinitions" - Joe Perez' reply (also posted or mentioned on several other forums)
- "Wilber and Aurobindo" - my counter-reply
Although Joe and I may differ intellectually (I mean it is really only on the matter of KW, he likes Wilber and AQAL while I take a contrary position) I think highly of him, and feel that at bottom Integralism is still about a common goal (more on this in a follow up post). He sent me a short friendly email concerning my reply to his critique. But not suire if the debate is going any further for now. So if anyone else wants to jump in on either side of the debate, or alternatively propose their own pov, that would help carry things along
Labels: AQAL, debate, Integral World, Joe Perez, Redefining Integral
posted by m alan kazlev at 6:22 PM
3 Comments:
In my opinion, both are right with their arguments. I don't want to join with any one because, I didn't felt one is wrong. It is a nice post for me. I really enjoyed your debate. I was in searching something related to your topic and also I got a good description from a writing service which I found from essay writing service reviews site.
When some students hear the word “essay” they may feel a little intimidated, but writing an essay doesn’t have to be scary at all. Essays take many forms, from answering a question on an exam to drafting a formal persuasive piece. Learning the basic format of an essay and practicing often helps students feel more confident when it’s time to write. Only a best essays writing service can perform as a perfect guide to student’s successful academic career.
This comment has been removed by the author.
Post a Comment
<< Home